I’m sure most of you have heard by now of Malika Calhoun–the 15 year old African American girl that was beaten by police officers for kicking a shoe at them (which didn’t hit either officer). (possible trigger warning for the rest of the post)

Today she spoke on CBS. Please be warned before you watch the video that the full video of her beating is in the piece. It is triggering. Be careful watching (if you can’t watch, you can turn away from the screen, there’s no sound on the beating or, you could go here and read the transcript).


Watch CBS Videos Online

This is not new. Many people are confused, how could police brutality be about women except in the most existential way (i.e. a mother loses her son, a sister loses a brother, etc)? This is how. When a young girl is arrested (for eating a french fry, dropping cake on the floor, pretending parsley is pot, having sex with a boyfriend), the male with her is probably not going to be arrested–AND grown ass men feel perfectly comfortable beating the shit out of a female half their size–many times even raping her.

Two Officers Accused of Raping an Intoxicated Woman They Escorted Home

By MICHAEL WILSON and MATHEW R. WARREN
Published: March 1, 2009

Two police officers have been assigned to desk
duty while prosecutors and the police investigate
a complaint that at least one of them raped an
intoxicated woman after they escorted her into
her apartment in the East Village three months ago, the police said on Sunday.

Footage from a nearby bar’s video surveillance
camera shows the two officers helping the woman
into her building on Dec. 7 and returning twice
during the next two hours, according to the bar
owner, who provided the video to investigators.

The officers have been placed on modified duty
and have had to turn in their guns and badges
while investigators from the Police Department
and the Manhattan district attorney’s office look
into the accusations of rape and another=2 0
accusation of drug possession, the police said.
No arrests have been made, the police said.

“The Internal Affairs Bureau is conducting an
investigation of the allegations,” said Paul J.
Browne, the department’s chief spokesman. He
declined to identify the officers or say whether
they worked out of the Ninth Precinct, which
includes the neighborhood where the woman lives.
The district attorney’s office declined to comment through a spokeswoman.

Stephen C. Worth, a lawyer for one of the officers, denied the allegations.

“The district attorney’s office has taken some
time in investigating this matter, and it is my
expectation that at the conclusion of their
investigation, they will determine that no crime
was committed,” Mr. Worth said.

The owner of the bar, Heather Millstone, 34, said
she gave the district attorney’s office footage
from a camera near the door of the bar on East
13th Street after two women arrived on Dec. 7 and
said their friend had been attacked in her nearby
apartment early that morning. The woman, who her
friends said was in a hospital, had told them, “
‘I’ve been raped. It was the police,’ ” Ms. Millstone said.

The three of them watched the video, which
includes a time stamp, Ms. Millstone said, and
saw one officer arrive at 1:10 a.m. and open the
front door20of the building as a second officer
helped the intoxicated woman inside. The friends
said the woman had been sick in a taxicab, and
the cab driver had called 911, Ms. Millstone said.

“She’s really clearly impaired” Ms. Millstone said.

The officers can be seen leaving the building
seven minutes after they entered, she said. They
returned 39 minutes later, at 1:59 a.m., and
followed a resident who used a key to enter the
building, Ms. Millstone said. One officer looked
up and seemed to notice the camera, she said.

The officers can be seen leaving the second time
after 17 minutes, seeming to move quickly out of
the camera’s range, Ms. Millstone said.

The officers can be seen returning to the
building the third time at 2:59 a.m., this time
entering with a key, Ms. Millstone said. “They’re
coming in from behind the camera, so that their
backs are to the camera,” she said.

The officers are seen leaving the building 34
minutes later, at 3:33 a.m., for the last time, she said.

“We made copies of the video,” she said. “I gave
the copies to her friends so she could give them
to her lawyer and the lawyer could take them directly to the D.A.’s office.”

She said soon afterward she received a call from
the district attorney’s office, “and they started their investigation.=E 2

News of the investigation was reported on Sunday
in The New York Post and The New York Daily News.

Mr. Worth declined to comment on the video, and
refused to identify the lawyer for the other officer.

One of the officers also faces an allegation of
drug possession after heroin was found in his
locker during a search that followed the
complaint, Mr. Browne said. Mr. Worth declined to
comment on that allegation. A spokesman for the
police officers’ union declined to comment on the case.

Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg mentioned the
investigation on Sunday while speaking to
reporters outside a church in Brooklyn. “It is a
very serious charge, obviously, and I don’t want
to prejudice anything, but you can rest assured
that the Internal Affairs Bureau is working very
hard and doing an investigation,” he said.

Martin Kynaston, an owner of Drop Off Service, a
bar near the one owned by Ms. Millstone, said
detectives visited him in December and asked for
video footage, but would not say why.

“The police said we’d read about it in the newspapers,” Mr. Kynaston said.
Recommend Next Article in New York Region (6 of
16) » A version of this article appeared in print
on March 2, 2009, on page A19 of the New York edition.

Again, police raping women they are supposed to be protecting is not unusual.

When a woman of color who knows what happens when her friends are arrested, who has held hands with friends who have been assaulted by officers, who doesn’t know what to do when she finds her own self pushed up against a police car with a man’s fingers up her private area (yes, this has happened), where is this woman supposed to turn to when she finds herself getting beaten by her partner? Or her child falls off a bed and needs an ambulance to get to a hospital?

As the mother of a mouthy girl, sweet JESUS when are we going to wake up and recognize the very real THREAT our girls are living under?


5 responses to “Teen Beaten by Police Speaks Out”

  1. Radfem

    There’s a local blogger writing on the Malika Calhoun case here.

    He’s written a lot on King County deputies including correctional.

  2. Renee

    I wrote a post detailing the violent attacks that black women face from the police. I personally don’t believe that it gets enough attention. Whenever we think of police brutality we always think about black men and yet black women are very much under attack. Officer friendly often does more than violently beat us as you pointed out he also rapes. Only white people can afford to see the police as a benign force, to us they are more like legalized terror roaming our neighborhoods.

  3. bfp

    I would argue, Renee, that it’s only white men who can afford that luxury–I’ve seen tapes of women getting assaulted–one woman the guy comes in, theres a lot of yelling, then the video blacks out–and when the video comes back on, the woman is laying like a limp noodle on the ground with a masssive wash of blood surrounding her face. the “after” pictures have her with two massive black eyes and a broken nose–she was a mess. And then I saw this video with these young white kids who were skate boarding and this officer comes up and attacks one of the kids…the only ones I’ve never ever seen treated with violence and degradation is white men. Which is probably why things never change. If it was white men being beaten until they are bloody pulps…fuck, could you imagine what would have happened if something like what happened in this video happened to scooter libby?

  4. Mamita Mala

    What bothers me so much is that when we, meaning women of color talk about these things, we are attacked instead of listened to. It seems that no matter how many times these crimes happen, they are dismissed as a one time thing or one bad apple when really together they prove just how dangerous to our lives law enforcement has become.

  5. Lyndsay

    Wow. I would add that I’m sure white men from certain (poor) neighbourhoods are more at risk too. A girl told me her brother got beat up by police so badly enough to go to the hospital. I wonder if it’s more common, even among more white men than you’d think to not trust police. Neither my dad nor my partner trust police very much.

What do you think?